The Sierra is one of the clumpiest boots on test, with a distinct lack of springiness in the sole, although that will be an advantage for anyone who likes a firm boot or just enjoys stomping. The dark brown leather style is horribly dated, unless you like the old-school ‘Kendal Mint Cake’ rambler look. The best thing about it is the price.

Stockists: 01702 541771

Salomon has spent a lot of time improving its walking boots and with the Alp 5 that effort pays off. It’s comfortable at pace even over rugged terrain, and the waterproof, breathable Gore-Tex outer is extremely effective. Design-wise it does say ‘ice boot without the blade’, but it’s a high-quality boot at a good price, which is the most important thing.

Stockists: 0800 389 4350

It looks good but it’s expensive, and it’s hard to see Timberland as a performance rather than fashion brand. This boot is ideally suited to what one manufacturer called ‘urbaneering’, but the laces are awkward and it proved impossible to find a comfortable position for the tongue at any point during the test. The one in the shoe, that is, not the one in MF’s mouth.

Stockists: 01753 497 100

Berghaus is a tried and trusted source for outdoor clothing such as jackets and fleeces, so it’s surprising to find nothing remarkable about this boot. That said, there’s nothing really wrong with it either – it’s comfortable and sturdy enough, with good waterproofing and breathability thanks to the use of Gore-Tex – but there are better boots for the price.

Stockists: 0191 516 5700

This is a good-looking, comfortable and stable boot that performs well over a variety of terrains (including, after all that walking, the carpet between the front door and the sofa). The Gore-Tex technology keeps your feet dry but also stops them overheating, although the three-figure price just pushes the Supalite out of the ‘great value’ category.

Stockists: 0191 516 5780

The Chameleon II is surprisingly solid and robust for a lightweight boot. In trying to establish itself in a crowded market Merrell scores well for design, although the laces are slightly too fiddly for quick and easy use, which can be annoying when all you want to do is get the damned things off. The padded collars took a bit of wearing in too but it’s worth it – this is a good boot at a fair price.

Stockists: 0117 963 6363

It’s hard to fault this boot – it looks and feels like it’s made for some serious walking and gives a solid, assured performance. It is springy in the step with convincing grip, and is easily both the lightest and best-quality boot on test. Some people may not be so keen on the red ribbon trim, though.

Stockists: 0800 612 9292